My Response to Questions from the Finance Committee

At my presentation today to the Finance Committee, the CPC members seemed quite shocked that the research would indicate that their Children’s Fitness Tax credit was ineffective, after all, they each had anecdotes from constituents that the tax credit was the only reason why their kids were active in sport.

Of course, you and I know that the plural of anecdotes is not data, so I happily provided them with the data related to the ineffectiveness of the Children’s Fitness Tax Credit. I attached for the consideration of the committee the evidence, along with several popular articles written by my fellow tax policy academic colleagues Kevin Milligan, UBC, and Frances Woolley, Carleton, that provide easily consumable summaries of this research.

Here it is for your consumption:

Academic Evidence

Popular Summaries of the Evidence

I would note carefully that neither myself nor any these attachments indicated that the goal of the CFTC, to increase sport participation, is not laudible. In addition, neither myself nor the research indicated that there are not some benefits to low and moderate income households and there is not some increase in sport participation. Rather, the majority of the benefits accrue to high income households and to parents of children who would participate in sport with or without the tax credit.

It is possible to use the funds dedicated to the CFTC to better target households to achieve the stated goals of the CFTC without the unintended consequence of subsidizing high income households (such as my own). I mentioned a few and my colleagues whose work I attach here mention other possibilities as well.

Thanks

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “My Response to Questions from the Finance Committee

  1. […] and it is worth 50% of that claim. I have written a lot about the federal version of this (here, here, and here), and my critiques apply here: this is a tax credit that predominantly benefits high […]

  2. […] Tax Credit has been “a waste of time.” (You can read my ruminations on this tax credit here, here, and here) After all, she writes, it “enjoys widespread support” among Canadian families and it […]

  3. […] full committee transcript here. Tedds has posted her speaking notes here and links to research here. Our Kevin Milligan previously summarized the research […]

  4. […] budget kicked this off with the elimination of the tax credits for child fitness and arts (here, here, and here) along with the tuition and textbook amounts, but then proceeded to introduce similar […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s